Skip to content

NYC City Council Votes To Destroy Coney Island

July 30, 2009

Only two City Council Reps, Charles Barron and Tony Avella, had the courage to support the community by voting to save Coney Island. Barron is not running for mayor this year, but Avella is. Avella for Mayor!

Democrat primary election day is September 15th, 2009.

Coney Island Gets a Facelift

by Courtney Gross
Gotham Gazette
July 30, 2009

[ image From City Planning’s Coney Island Redevelopment Plan can be viewed at

In an attempt to revitalize an area long known as “America’s playground,” the City Council approved a 27-acre redevelopment plan[] to turn Coney Island into a year-round destination, full of retail, hotels and entertainment.

Call it Las Vegas a la Brooklyn.

With both indoor and outdoor amusements, the controversial redevelopment[], which was approved by a vote of 44 to 2 with one abstention, is intended to bring back the Coney Island circa 1930s[] when the area was flooded with vacationers and New Yorkers looking for sun and sand.

Council members Tony Avella and Charles Barron voted against the plan, saying it would take away Coney Island’s character and the city did not factor in enough of the community’s concerns. Rosie Mendez abstained.

In addition to the Coney Island redevelopment plan[], the City Council also approved several bills to improve bike access in the city, including requiring bike parking in certain parking garages.
Coney Island Redevelopment

Morphing mostly vacant lots into parkland, the plan could include as many as four high-rise hotels along Surf Avenue and at least 10 acres dedicated solely for amusement. The amusement area[] will be a mix of indoor and outdoor entertainment, anything from arcades and freak shows to art galleries and restaurants.

Though the council has approved the plan, the deal is not entirely etched in stone yet. Much of the success of Coney Island depends on a potential deal with a local developer, Joseph J. Sitt, chief executive officer of Thor Equities[]. Thor owns several acres eyed by the city for the entertainment and amusement district. For months, the Bloomberg administration and the developer have been negotiating[] the price of the property, and at one point were considering a land swap.

Yesterday city officials appeared very close to an agreement[] with Sitt, which could allow the city to purchase six of Sitt’s 10 acres.

In a statement yesterday, Stefan Friedman, a spokesman for Thor Equities, said: “Thor is continuing to work with the administration to ensure the best outcome for Coney Island. We are hopeful that these negotiations will result in a timely resolution and a brighter day for Coney.”

Sitt had been involved in the redevelopment of Coney Island back in 2002, when the local councilmember, Domenic Recchia, asked for his help in revitalizing the all too often vacant amusement area.

Recchia, an ally of Sitt, had held up his own support[] of the project in part because the administration and the developer could not come to an agreement.

In response to the City Council’s approval, Mayor Michael Bloomberg said in a prepared statement: “We’ve still got a lot of work to do in the days ahead. We have every reason to feel optimistic because we’re working aggressively to iron out the terms of deals with landowners. And we will also continue working with our partners in Albany to gain approval for the parkland legislation we need for the development to move forward.”

Yesterday, Recchia spoke confidently of the plan, saying a new school, community center, and job creation programs will all create a better Coney Island.

“Not everyone got what they wanted. We tried to make as many people as happy as we can,” said Recchia. Eventually, he later added, “we will see the world’s greatest playground come back better than ever.”

It is true that not everyone is happy. Community advocates from the get-go voiced concern over the amount of space dedicated to outdoor amusement. Pointing to the smaller rides that had taken up much of the space of Coney Island in recent decades, opponents of the plan, like the Save Coney Island coalition, were dismayed that it did not include more outdoor amusements, similar to the Cyclone and the Wonder Wheel — both of which are included in the redevelopment.

At yesterday’s council meeting, the balcony was full of protestors who held white signs saying, “Don’t Save Coney Island. Fix the Plan.”

Following the vote, Steve Peluso of Save Coney Island, wrote in an e-mail: “These flaws in the plan are obviously concessions to property owner Joe Sitt, CEO of Thor Equities, who invaded Coney Island under the pretense of building a new amusement park there, but instead transformed a large majority of the area into a blighted empty lot in hopes of bullying the city into buying him out or up-zoning his land. The City Council today played right into his hands.”

Some council members agreed with them.

When voting against the plan yesterday, Barron said, “There are some people in Coney Island who are not settling. I’ve talked to grassroots groups who feel like Coney Island will be Cozy Island for the elite.”

Currently, according to the Department of City Planning, out of 50,000 residents of the area about one in six live in New York City Housing Authority projects. At least 25 percent of the population is over 60 years old, and unemployment is twice the city’s average.

The plan, according to city officials, will help turn those statistics around.

According to city officials, the amusement area will be surrounded by about 4,500 new residences, which at least 35 percent are slated for affordable housing. The original Coney Island proposal by the Bloomberg administration included only 20 percent affordable housing. About half of the affordable housing will have a home ownership option, said Council Speaker Christine Quinn. The city will set aside about $15 million for boardwalk reconstruction and $137 million to improve sewage and stormwater infrastructure in the area.
Bike Parking and Access

Also yesterday, the council approved two bills to spur more New Yorkers to commute via bicycle. The first bill (Intro 871) will require commercial buildings with freight elevators to allow employees to take their bicycles into work. The bill, said Quinn, will affect 1,600 commercial buildings, a little less than a quarter of all of the city’s commercial buildings.

The second bill (Intro 780) will require parking garages with more than 100 parking spots provide parking spaces for bicycles. A bike spot would be mandated for every 10 vehicle parking spots, up to 200 spots.

Both bills were approved by a vote of 46 to 1, with Councilmember Erik Martin Dilan dissenting.

For the first two years, the bike parking bill will capture 650 garages and create 1,000 bike spaces, city officials said. After two years the bill will apply to garages of 51 or more spaces.
From Smoking to Pedicabs

Also on Wednesday, the council approved a bill (Intro 642) that will ban smoking on the grounds or within 15 feet of an entrance to a hospital, diagnostic treatment center or residential health care facility.

The council unanimously approved a bill (Intro 1031) that would regulate pedicabs, requiring every operator obtain a license and train its drivers.

Also unanimously, the council approved a veto override (Intro 992), which will allow every city employee to live in six surrounding counties after completing two years of employment. Currently, most employees must reside within the five boroughs permanently.

Deal on Coney Island

By Courtney Gross
Gotham Gazette
July 21st, 2009

The City Council’s committees on zoning and land use both approved the redevelopment plan [] for Coney Island this afternoon, including revisions that take the property surrounding the Wonder Wheel out of an established parkland area.

The deal, which was brokered between the Bloomberg administration and the area’s Councilmember Domenic Recchia, would also include a pedestrian walkway along Wonder Wheel Way.

The plan was approved by the zoning committee by a vote of 5 to 1, with chairman Tony Avella dissenting. It was approved by a vote of 13 to 2 in the land use committee, with Avella and Charles Barron dissenting.

Up until yesterday, Recchia’s support [] was not guaranteed. In a press release in full after the jump, Recchia explains why he changed his mind this afternoon, saying he can support the deal because it includes money for Coney Island Hospital and it would create local jobs.

It is unclear how this deal would affect Coney Island developer Joseph Sitt []. Sitt owns at least five acres the city would like to acquire for its plan.

What is clear is that not everyone will be happy with the deal. Save Coney Island[], a coalition that was lobbying for changes in the development plan, wanted the amount of amusement space in the plan doubled and wanted to do away with the high-rise hotels planned for Surf Avenue. Neither of those concessions were included in this deal.

Here is Recchia’s full press release:


I am pleased to announce that, with my support, the Land Use Committee passed a broad, sweeping and ambitious rezoning plan that will reshape Coney Island and return the iconic neighborhood to the prestige of its past.

Coney Island today lacks year-round jobs and necessary infrastructure. It has limited amusements and properties that have fallen fallow. This project is as an opportunity to provide necessary amenities to the 50,000 people who call Coney Island home, including year-round jobs paying livable wages and affordable housing, as well as improvements to the amusement and entertainment areas for the millions who visit Coney Island.

One of my goals in this project was to make sure that those who had stayed in the community and invested during the tough times were respected in any plan that went forward. I am happy to report that the owners of the Wonder Wheel are supportive of the project. The owners of Gargiulo’s have also had input into the redevelopment, and are pleased about their continued future in Coney Island. I have had countless discussions with all of the stakeholders, and listened to hours of testimony at public hearings both here and in Coney Island.

I would like to have been able to expand the area available for open amusements, and I have been actively discussing this with the administration. Those discussions have been fruitful and are ongoing. I hope that by the time the entire City Council votes on this plan, on July 29th, I will have great news for everyone. But I am confident that this project, as it currently stands, is good for the city, good for Brooklyn and great for Coney Island.

Similarly, I know that there are those who would like to see lower buildings on the south side of Surf Avenue. We just couldn’t make this work and will be moving forward with project that you see today.

The trade off has been worth it: We’re getting a first-class amusement park, the long-awaited new gym for P.S. 188, infrastructure work to improve the bad drainage and sewer problems that have plagued the peninsula, a new skating rink in Coney Island that will continue to serve the hockey leagues as well as local residents and their families, new affordable housing opportunities including exciting home ownership opportunities along with funds to assist in mortgage down payments, and funds for the renovation of the Boardwalk and Dreier-Offerman Park.

The administration has made commitments to encourage local hiring, to provide training for local residents in the food service and hospitality industries, and long-term strategies to help address the high rates of unemployment in the community. With all of these new visitors to Coney Island, it is important that we have a first class trauma and emergency room to handle any emergencies. The administration is committed to upgrading and modernizing the facilities at Coney Island Hospital to handle the capacities of the current and future residents and visitors.

As I’ve said all along, it’s impossible to make everyone 100 percent happy. This plan accomplishes the goal of making everyone happy enough that we can move forward together toward a revitalized Coney Island. I would like to thank my colleagues for voting in favor of this plan. By doing so, we take the first steps toward restoring the glamour, the glory and the greatness of Coney Island.

No comments yet

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: